“Who Is Agent 37?”
Harley, Constantine, Simon, and Azrael are invited to a room. James shows up, and asks them to each tell the story of the time they met Agent 37. At the end, they guess his secret identity. James reveals that he is actually Dick, and he uses the hypnos in his blood to make them all forget their adventures with him and his identity. He leaves and goes on an adventure with Helena.
“The Charmer”
Constantine shares the story of when He met Agent 37.
He was investigating missing men when he found a lair where four vampires were feeding off a victim. He had difficulty getting in, and assumed the man was dead. When he distracted the vampires, the victim, Agent 37, escaped and took down all the vampires. Constantine was annoyed he didn't get the satisfaction of destroying them himself.
“The Savior”
Azrael tells the story of when he met Agent 37 (for the second time).
Azrael was helping defend a refugee camp from the Order of Dumas. Agent 37 showed up to steal a holy relic, but stays to help fight off the order. He uses Azrael's sword to destroy their attack vehicle. Together, they stopped the attackers. Dick told both Azrael and Matron the relic was destroyed, but actually left it behind for the people.
“The Gymnast”
Harley shares the story of when she met Agent 37.
She was casing out a place where a party was happening. The owner collected super-villain memorabilia. She saw another guy, Agent 37 casing it, so she invited him to work together. He used his hypnos to find out where the stuff was stored, and she used gas to clear out the party goers. They used their combined gymnast skills to get through the laser security. They found a container of Joker toxin, which Harley promised to destroy. The parted ways.